Ludwig van Beethoven, Richard Goode - Beethoven: The Complete Sonatas
|
Our Price: $99.98 Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Used: from $56.95 (click here) Category: Music CD See more new music releases 
|
|---|
Buy this Music CD at online store in your country
Canadian Music Store
Canadian Music Store
Free Music Notes for Beethoven: The Complete Sonatas
Free Music Review: Beautifully musical
Hit: 5 Stars
I have been thoroughly enjoying Goode's recordings, not because they are the most precise or powerful of the recordings (Perahia and Gilels are in my opinion the real stand-outs under those criteria), but rather because they are beautifully musical. Most of the pianists who have published recordings of Beethoven's piano sonatas are technically proficient enough to do a passable job, but not all of the recordings are actually interesting to listen to. From this perspective, Goode's recordings are among my favorite.Free Music Review: The earlier the composition the better the playing
Hit: 4 Stars
Richard Goode's Beethoven sonata traversal is impressive, no doubt about that. His technique is clean and his attention to dynamics and other score markings is impeccable. Goode emphasizes the classicism of the composition, and to the extent that the sonatas are strictly classical (100% correspondence through #21, opus 53, the "Waldstein")
Oddly, perhaps, I listened to this complete sonata set in reverse, starting with opus 111 and ending with opus 2. This way of hearing the evolution of the sonatas in reverse gave me a certain perspective on the issue of classical versus nonclassical (Romantic, content no longer matched equally with form) that sort of jumped out at me. As structures and compositional methods simplified (in backwards time) the essence of Beethoven's thinking became more clear, making the earliest sonatas seem more powerful and intense than they usually tend to be. (Or maybe it is Goode's playing of them, after all.)
The three sonatas that make up opus 2 (f minor, A major, C major) have probably never been played or thought through so well as in this set. The excellence continues unmitigated through sonata #21 (the "Waldstein"). In fact, Goode's rendering of the "Waldstein" is as good as it gets and, as it were, knocked my socks clean off technically (blazing speed with clarity) and interpretively. Other great Beethoven players such as Rudolf Serkin, Kempff, Arrau, and Barenboim may bring this or that in varying degrees to the table, but none has any overall advantage over Goode for sonatas #1 through #21. Then, to my mind, things change. The playing remains clean and highly literal to the end of the cycle but the nobility and imagination required to present the later sonatas is lacking. Goode made me wonder why Beethoven wrote #29 (the "Hammerklavier"), for example, and left me wanting substance in opera 109, 110, and 111.
However, there are precious few complete sets of these benchmarks of Western cultural achievement, so one should not be overly harsh with any that are for the most part successful, as this set by Goode undoubtedly is. One other thing: The recorded sound is sub-par, somewhat muffled and lacking presence. Once can train oneself to ignore this but why should one have to when alternatives with outstanding recorded sound exist. Goode should have been better served in this regard.
Bottom line: Serious Beethoven people should experience this set. Those who only buy one set might consider Kempff or Barenboim instead.
Free Music Review: why!?
Hit: 2 Stars
I can't understand why all the fuss about this item. The authors of the penguin guide accorded such distinctions to Goode's recording of Beethoven's sonatas that I decided to give it a listen and finally discover what new ground it was breaking. As I turned off my stereo and absent-mindedly put the cds back in their beautiful cases I began to feel that disturbing anguish which often arises from having spent too much money on a basically dull and disappointing item. Germans poetically call it Gewissensbisse, literally ''bites on the counsciousness''; we call it ''remorse''. Goode adds nothing new to our understanding of Beethoven's music, nor does he disclose new aspects of the sonatas which could have been overlooked by those who trod this path before him. If a pianist is intent on treading a path which has already been followed thousands of times before, he's expected at least to justify why he thinks his particular take on the work in question should be heard by the average listener who's already acquainted with it through the recordings of eminent figures like Kempff, Ashkenazy, Barenboim, Arrau and many others, and why a newcomer to Beethoven's music should buy his performance rather than the hundreds of others that are already available on the market. To sum up, he's expected to provide something different and relevant. Goode unfortunately fails to meet all these conditions. Free Music Review: Elevator Music
Hit: 1 Stars
I tried to like this set- I really did. This was my first set of Beethoven's complete sonata's - it got great reviews and I was excited to get it but try as I might I had trouble enjoying it. Where was the passion, the dynamism, the creativity I associated with Beethoven? It was work getting through it - the music seemed dull, lacking in profundity and spontaneity. There was a kind of elegaic beauty to it to be sure but Goode seemed to me to be connecting with this music as from a great distance, as if it was a story he was telling about long, long ago.
Then I picked up the Gulda set and there it was; the power, the dyanmism, the felicity, poetry and spontaneity of Beethoven. I tried Goode again, I thought maybe I had missed something but no, while it was pretty and elegant, the magic of Beethoven was gone again. For me this was homogenized Beethoven.
Free Music Review: Richard Goode Plays Beethoven Sonatas
Hit: 5 Stars
Richard Goode Plays Beethoven's Thirty-two Sonatas for Piano
I was looking through my mementos for the concert programs they used to have in St Paul's and Trinity Church down on Wall Street during lunch hours. For two days a week back in the 1970's, `80's and 90's when I was on Wall Street these sister Episcopalian churches would have noonday concerts. In fact, that's what they were called, Noonday Concerts. I remember that I had not previously heard Richard Goode play, but I had heard of him, and when Trinity Church announced that he was to play some Beethoven sonatas at the Noonday Concerts I thought I'd go hear him. Back in those days these concerts were free, and they frequently had distinguished, well-known artists . I was with my first wife when I first went to hear him. I mention this because it wasn't until years later, when I was with my present wife, that I discovered that my teacher, John Kamitsuka, was a student of Goode's.
The first time I saw RG, he came out of the left side of the Trinity Church altar at a fairly brisk pace, with a shy but friendly smile on his face, went to the piano, took a short bow, looked once around the audience, and promptly seated himself at the piano. He took some time to adjust the bench and then rubbed his hands together, looked up briefly, and then he launched into the Beethoven. More than launched, actually, he recreated the Beethoven. I didn't know it at the time, but he was in the midst of a ten year project to record all thirty-two sonatas and he was playing three or four a year in these concerts. I don't remember what he played that day or on the two or three more occasions I had over the next few years to hear him play, but I was so pleased with his performance that I tried not to miss any opportunity to hear him play.
I had bought this set some years ago and have had the occasion recently to study it. (I'm on this jag to start enjoying all the good stuff I have while I'm still kicking.) After listening to the set a few times, I felt that I had this bag of jewels and I could put my hand in and out would come this jewel or that jewel and each jewel was as beautiful as the others. In this set, there's not a bad jewel in the bunch.
So now, quoth he, what about this set? You will find that Goode has an impressive dynamic range and that the architecture of his interpretations is very cohesive: he's put a lot of thought into structure and the results are very convincing. His playing is pellucid, with hardly any blurring due to pedal. When he does blur, it's clearly for effect. He has a magnificent technique and he plays with the energetic forthrightness that is required by the music, but his playing is not strident. He prefers subtle coloring effects and precise rhythms to express the deeper dimensions of these pieces. One thing you will notice is that his hands are absolutely independent. For example, he does this trick throughout: he'll begin a crescendo, but the right hand will `crescend' sooner than the left- and the left may actually get louder and softer while the right hand continues. It makes the playing very colorful.
And now some specifics: (things that I especially like)
Sonata #2, third mvt, Scherzo
#5, third mvt, Finale (here is one place that I really get the sense of the terrific architectural coherence of his playing)
#6, third mvt, Presto: fun
#'s 10,11, 12- three gems.
#10, first mvt, Allegro
#10, third mvt, Allegro assai: perfection.
#12, fourth mvt, Allegro
#13, second mvt, Allegro molto vivace: specifically timing/rhythm
#15
#18, first mvt, Allegro
#21, last two mvts, very contemplative interpretations, different. I think I prefer Schnabel here, especially last mvt.
#26, Das Lebwohl, Les Adieux. I think this is my favorite performance of this sonata, especially the last mvt. RG brings out all the joy that Beethoven must have felt on the return of his friend and patron.
#29, fourth mvt, Fuga. Very powerful reading. (Aside: compare the music here with the Grosse Fuge, Op 133 String quartet.)
#30, another great reading. I especially like the third mvt, variations #'s II & IV
#31 L'inversione della fuga: very powerful reading
Back in the days when I was working with Kamitsuka, I asked him who his favorite living pianists were. He said Martha Argerich was `pretty good'. That's about as high a compliment as he was willing to make for any living pianist. (He had a lot to say about bad pianists.) Then some time later RG came out with a Brahms CD. I said to Kamitsuka, `You know, John, Richard Goode just came out with a cd of Brahms late works.' He looked at me briefly and then looked away out the window that had a view of the Palisades in New Jersey and said, `Oh yeah? Hmm... it must be pretty good.'
So, hope you enjoy these as much as I have.