Ludwig van Beethoven: The 9 Symphonies - Arturo Toscanini / NBC Symphony Orchestra
|
List Price: Our Price: $26.99 You Save: $2.99 (10%) Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Used: from $17.48 (click here) Category: Music CD See more new music releases 
|
|---|
Buy this Music CD at online store in your country
Canadian Music Store
Canadian Music Store
Free Music Notes for Ludwig van Beethoven: The 9 Symphonies - Arturo Toscanini / NBC Symphony Orchestra
Free Music Review: If only ...
Hit: 4 Stars
I have the Karajan Beethoven cycle from 1963 and that was really my first exposure. I love the deep sound of Karajan. I bought this cycle on a whim and I am thrilled that I did. It is a whole new Beethoven, slimmed down, quicker and more exciting. Less ponderous and really breathtaking.
Still, there is no getting around the slightly tinny and less full sound that stems, I must believe, from the fact that this is not recorded in stereo...so, if only. If only we had a legacy of Toscanini's interpretation that was as crisp sounding as it must have been to live audiences at the time.
UPDATE - So it has been a few weeks and I have listened to other newer recordings at a faster pace, including Zinman and Norrington... And I still prefer Toscanini, especially his interpretation of the 1st symphony. Neither Zinman nor Norrington come close. I like Norrington's 8th, but as a set, this Toscanini rocks- especially knocks out Karajan, about whom, truthfully, I cannot see what all the fuss is about.
At this price though, I think you must buy it and listen to what a great Beethoven can sound like and hope that someone new comes along to record it using today's technology and Toscanini's insights...
Free Music Review: Recorded in the 50s, and it shows
Hit: 3 Stars
Toscanini is brilliant in his interpretation of Beethoven, but these recordings were made a long time ago, and despite every effort, the sound is not very good. This is an excellent recording for someone wanting to hear Toscanini, but not as much for someone who wants to hear Beethoven.Free Music Review: Beethoven's Nine Symphonies
Hit: 5 Stars
The sound quality of the symphonies vary, depending on where the recording comes from. I list that information here from the booklet included with the box set. Recordings from Carnegie Hall sound better, comparable to Deutsche Grammaphon early stereo recordings. Recordings from NBC Broadcasts generally sound like early live recordings, comparable to the sound quality of EMI's recording of Furtwangler's performance of the Ninth (Great Recordings of the Century).
No. 1 - Recorded December 21, 1951 in Carnegie Hall
No. 2 - Recorded November 7, 1949 & October 9, 1951 in Carnegie Hall
No. 3 - NBC Broadcast of December 6, 1953 in Carnegie Hall
Note: Unfortunately the worst sound-quality of the set; some coughs are audible in the quiet parts; I want to go back in time and give the guy a cough drop. But the performance is incredible; indeed an honorable mention for this work in "1001 Classical Recordings You Must Hear Before You Die". I think it's worth it to have Toscanini's performance over one with better sound but muddled conducting (ahem...Karajan 1963...ahem)
No. 4 - NBC Broadcast of February 3, 1951 in Carnegie Hall
No. 5 - NBC Broadcast of March 22, 1952 in Carnegie Hall
Note: Fortunately, this one is an exception and sounds much better than the other broadcasts. I think Toscanini does the BEST rendition of the famous eight note intro (even better than Kleiber's too melodramatic reading).
No. 6 - Recorded January 14, 1952 in Carnegie Hall
Note: Smooth and lush sound, a beautiful piece in Toscanini's hands that doesn't get "smothered" in "sentimentality" (quoted from the booklet). The booklet states that Toscanini's "retouchings of Beethoven's orchestration" in the 4th mvmt's storm provide one example to counter the "absurd notion" that Toscanini played everything "exactly as written". What, I ask, is the problem with playing pieces exactly as written? I guess we can't give Beethoven too much credit (sarcasm).
No. 7 - Recorded November 9, 1951 & NBC broadcast of November 10, 1951 in Carnegie Hall
No. 8 - Recorded November 10, 1952 in Carnegie Hall
No. 9 - Recorded March 31-April 1, 1952 in Carnegie Hall
Note: Best sound of them all, and the perfect finish is worth the whole set. Compare Toscanini's 2nd mvmt time - 13:09 - to Furtwangler's 12:00, Karajan's 11:00, and Fricsay's 10:32, and decide of Toscanini conducts to fast. An essential Ninth.
Audiophiles with high performance speakers will probably settle for inferior (or less faithful) performances of these symphonies for high-tech recordings, so I don't recommend this for them. But I do recommend this for anyone who wants to hear all nine of Ludwig van Beethoven's symphonies.
My original review:
As a new fan of Beethoven, I searched for a set of his nine symphonies to listen to for the first time in my life. Needless to say, it had to be near perfection (and still fit into my college-student budget), and so I came upon this set of Toscanini's performances around 1950. A little research said that this was certainly a must-have, and a quick glance at the incredible price sealed the deal. As soon as it arrived, I spent the next couple of weeks finding a little place to be alone and listen to an entire symphony, and every single time it was amazing.
The sound quality is fine...reading the reviews made me worry that there'd be static or fuzz throughout the recording (bringing me bitter memories of my Benny Goodman at Carnegie Hall set, where the static overwhelmed the music). But no, the beautiful sound came through clear and pure.
I would recommend this even to beginners at classical music, since Toscanini's performances are powerful, intense, fun, and glorious...whatever Beethoven would have wanted.
The CDs are in a nice cardboard box and each CD is in its own cardboard sleeve with similar art as the cover you see pictured. Also included is a nice booklet (in three languages) that gives a neat history and brief analysis of each symphony, plus there was a picture of a page of Beethoven's draft of the Fifth and of his earpiece. The entire package is a nice and elegant presentation.
Free Music Review: very pleased
Hit: 5 Stars
This is a wonderful recording of Beethoven's symphanies. We are pleased with the quality of the recording, and the performance is outstanding.Free Music Review: The famous original Toscanini NBC recordings
Hit: 5 Stars
This is the true original item, with all its original defects and its exciting moments. The performances are as thrilling for me as they were 40 years ago!! The cream of the crop in my opinion is Toscanini's Eroica, the second movement is unparallelled by any other performance. So is the 9th, especially with Jan Pierce's extraordinary tenor. Yet throughout there are special moments, even the 4th sparkles.
The sound is generally below standard even for the early 50s, for the 9th it is acceptable. I find the coughing in some of the performances (which were concert performances) like the 3rd adds to the authenticity. You know these recordings were not spliced, and they carry the thrill of authentic performances!!