Rufus Wainwright - Rufus Does Judy At Carnegie Hall [2 CD]
![Rufus Does Judy At Carnegie Hall [2 CD]](/images/Rufus-Does-Judy-At-Carnegie-Hall-2-CD-B000XMZJX8-L.jpg)
|
List Price: Our Price: $9.90 You Save: $15.08 (60%) Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days Buy Used: from $3.43 (click here) Category: Music CD See more new music releases 
|
|---|
Buy this Music CD at online store in your country
Canadian Music Store
Canadian Music Store
Free Music Notes for Rufus Does Judy At Carnegie Hall [2 CD]
Free Music Review: Rufus does Judy
Hit: 4 Stars
I was apprehensive when I started to listen to this CD, and I was still a bit anxious after the first song, ("When You're Smiling"). But Rufus had me hooked after "Puttin' on the Ritz" and I was completely sold by the end of the first act, ("San Francisco"). After that, I was his, all the way to "Chicago".
Yes, he has his vocal quirks, but his enthusiasm and obvious love of the material more than make up for it. And the orchestra is fab.
It would have been easy to camp it up, but he elects to do the songs (you should pardon the expression) relatively straight. It's a joyous experience. Honestly, this is the most fun I've had listening to a CD in a long time.
I could have done without Martha Wainwright's "Stormy Weather", to be honest. And Lorna Luft's vibrato is kind of scary, although some of "After You've Gone" was pretty swell.
The pinnacle of the whole CD is Noel Coward's "If Love Were All". I'd love to hear Rufus tackle an entire CD of Coward's work. It seems their dry humor and bruised romanticism would be a perfect fit.
Anyway, if you're a Rufus fan, it's worth a listen.
Free Music Review: Somehow It Works
Hit: 4 Stars
When I first heard about this project, I thought it was the most insane idea I ever heard of. Who in their right mind would put themselves in competition with Judy Garland, song for song in one of her most famous stage appearances? At best, I thought it would be a sort of campy misfire. But somehow it all works. Once you get past his vocal limitations, this is quite an enjoyable experience. No one can compete with Garland's voice and Rufus doesnt try to compete with her. And to my surprise he does a good job, even with some missteps here and there (one mistake is deliberate, as Judy made the same mistake in her concert). Will you like it? I dont know. I'm a fan of both performers and I'd recommend this to anyone. At worst it'll make you want to buy/listen to the original which isnt a bad thing. It's a Wainwright family affair with Lorna Luft as a bonus Garland connection. I also recommend the DVD version which is even better as it has some extra encores on it. Bless Rufus' gay little heart!Free Music Review: As good as it gets
Hit: 4 Stars
I was very fortunate to see the second NYC show by Rufus. I was concerned he was too young and lacking in the vocal capabilities to interprete the material and the legacy of Judy. He was, on both counts in those areas and then not so in others He did very well considering the complete risk of the adventure. His versions of Judy's classics are a nice update with a man singing her pain/love. Rufus's sister, Martha was awesome and almost upstaged him - but people came to see a diva and that they got -- Rufus. He was electric in parts and overall brave, engaged and very courageous to even attempt to recreate the concert. Overall, it was every thing I expected and appreciated his talents even the more. Rufus came to entertain as a "performer" and that he did in spades.
Certainly look for greater and interesting things (his working opera?), as divas are sure hard to come by and Rufus is a blessed one. Keep your eye on him as his is an amazing and fearless talent.
Free Music Review: Rufus is as Rufus does
Hit: 4 Stars
Rufus Wainright is no Judy Garland. But once you get that image (and sound) out of your head, there are some wonderful moments on this "cover" of an entire unforgettable concert. Rufus continually amazes me with his musicality, vocal range, impertinence, audacity, and sheer talent. Still, I had to work at hearing him on this recording. The original is so indelibly imprinted on my soul. But the effort was worth the effort, and reaffirms my love affair with this amazing artist. I highly recommend this recording - just don't expect a Judy imitation. It's Rufus all the way, and he is equally unique in what he delivers.Free Music Review: Rufus Surprised Me Again
Hit: 4 Stars
I saw Rufus Wainwright's Hollywood Bowl version of Judy at Carnegie Hall in 2007 During the first number I became somewhat doubtful that his show would carry the impact I wanted it to for my pleasure. As he progressed through the show I found I was intrigued by his performance. His voice isn't of the belting variety by any means, but I found it truthful, gentle, and at times, perfect for the number he was doing. The album did the same thing to me. The more I listened the more I wanted to hear. The sincerity of his performance locked me in.